The Privilege of Politics

Actor Chris Pratt finds himself a target of left Hollywood and various social media enforcers for his apparent lack of support for Joe Biden, a sin in his industry. Pratt has endorsed neither Biden nor Trump, which seems eminently sensible for a boy-next-door type who plays superheroes and adventurers in big blockbusters. But staying quiet is never enough for the political jackals, who insist silence is violence and a form of privilege. Trump is a Nazi; his electorate is full of hateful fascist enablers and this is no time for quietude. To make matters worse, the reticent Pratt also belongs to a Christian church which is “anti-LGBT”—which is to say not anti-LGBT at all, but simply not in full conformity with the language and demands of its accusers.

When his actor friend and sometime costar Mark Ruffalo rushed to defend Pratt’s character, the Twitterati reacted angrily but predictably:

pratt1
Pratt2
Pratt3
Pratt4

This is a classic case of the Imposers positioning themselves as the Imposed Upon: LGBT advocates weaponize and contort simple words—hurt, harm, apathy, privilege, marginalized, vulnerable—in ways reminiscent of Orwell’s “Politics and the English Language.” They use words in consciously dishonest ways. They shift the parameters of what it means to “support” or “oppose” LGBT causes into a stark binary: you are for us or against us. Simply living one’s life peaceably is not an option in this bizarre worldview.

And the Imposer’s unconditional terms change constantly, seemingly overnight. One cannot avoid conflict by being “not overtly political,” as Ruffalo termed Pratt. The accusations against his church, for example, amount to nothing more than a demand for unconditional surrender of any theology or doctrine which does not comport with today’s instant (though far from universal) view of transgenderism. Unless and until that happens, his church is per se transphobic and evil: indifference, or even kind and loving disagreement, cannot satisfy the Imposers.

It does not matter whether Pratt’s church welcomes everyone, even those individuals it considers engaged in sin (which presumably includes just about every person on earth). It does not matter whether Pratt is a good person or friend to his fellow actors. His church must affirmatively endorse the views of LGBT activists; Pratt must actively endorse Biden. Anything else is weaponized privilege.

Of course this is nonsense, but the Imposers always claim to be the Imposed Upon. Media and politicians play along, and then social media voices join the chorus until the original reality becomes completely obscured: both Chris Pratt and his church were minding their own business and not hurting anyone. The Biden and LGBT activists came looking for them, not the other way around.

What incredible arrogance and hubris! This is real privilege: the privilege of demanding others not only share your political views but also see the world in starkly political terms. This is real hate, actual hate, not the phony kind imagined on Hate Has No Home Here yard signs.

When taken to an extreme, a positive rights worldview requires not only conformity and acquiescence with the political project of the day, but your affirmative participation. Not keeping up with the latest outrage, political machinations, or campaign—not leading a wholly political life—becomes a dereliction of duty.

Political liberty is quite simple, but not easy. We all owe our fellow citizens a duty not to aggress against them or their property, and not to commit fraud against them. In the broader societal sense, we all should strive to be kind, open, and generous with everyone we meet, unless and until they give us a reason to be otherwise. But that is all we owe. Being apolitical or even antipolitical is your absolute right. At best, politics is an uneasy and imperfect mechanism for peacefully transferring political power; at worst, it is barely a substitute for war. More commonly, politics is a turf battle waged by rival gangs to control the state apparatus (the turf is us and our money). Politics is not noble, virtuous, or even necessary. The people attacking Chris Pratt, and even hoping to harm his career, reputation, and finances, hold no moral high ground.

My great aunt, now departed, once told me about a decision she and her husband made as newlyweds just after World War II. Starting life together in a very modest house, they wanted to build lasting memories with family and friends. So they made a pact: they would never discuss politics in their home or allow guests to discuss politics. In her view politics was like sex and religion, a private matter. They wanted to avoid the disharmony and rancor they had witnessed among their own parents and families a decade earlier over the Roosevelt administration’s New Deal programs. They determined their hearth and home would be devoted to happiness, an apolitical refuge where every visitor would be welcome.

The goal is a less political world, not a world which bends to our political will. We are not Imposers. So participate in politics and voting if you like, or refrain if you like. Voting is optional and anonymous for a reason. But never let anyone force you into taking a political stance, or even to hold a political stance. In 2020, privilege manifests as political extortion. Push back against these bullies.Author:

Contact Jeff Deist

Jeff Deist is president of the Mises Institute. He previously worked as chief of staff to Congressman Ron Paul, and as an attorney for private equity clients. Contact: emailTwitter.

Creative Commons Licence
Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.

Image source: Svend Nielsen on Unsplash

When commenting, please post a concise, civil, and informative comment. Full comment policy here

ADD COMMENT

https://disqus.com/embed/comments/?base=default&f=misesinstitute&t_i=node%2F52488&t_u=https%3A%2F%2Fmises.org%2Fwire%2Fprivilege-politics&t_e=The%20Privilege%20of%20Politics&t_d=The%20Privilege%20of%20Politics%20%7C%20Mises%20Wire&t_t=The%20Privilege%20of%20Politics&s_o=default#version=9e072c150154e3eaaf066d104c0fab0e

Shield icon
wire

WHAT IS MISES WIRE?

Mises Wire offers contemporary news and opinion through the lens of Austrian economics and libertarian political economy.

Submitting articles to Mises Wire

Reprints, Permissions & Copyrights

The views expressed on Mises Wire and mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.MOST POPULAR WIRE ARTICLES

Social Media Companies Aren’t the Good Guys. They’re Also Not Monopolists. 

Ryan McMaken

Social media has lied about user privacy and has misled the public about the platforms’ status as open forums. But none of this makes these companies monopolies. 

The Privilege of Politics

Jeff Deist

In 2020, privilege manifests as political extortion. Push back against these bullies.

Will Democracy’s Myths Doom Liberty?

James Bovard

If Biden is elected, we will hear the same “redemption” storyline that was trumpeted when Obama replaced (temporarily) disgraced George W. Bush. The  media will insist that Biden’s inauguration purifies Uncle Sam.

How Decades of Media and Faculty Bias Have Pushed America to the Left

Ryan McMaken

Silicon Valley and the media are moving even further left. This is what is to be expected when a single ideological group controls educational institutions and major media outlets over a period of several decades.

Chile Won’t Become a Developed Country If It Doesn’t Change Course

Victor Espinosa

Twenty years ago, it looked like Chile was well on its way to joining the world’s small club of developed countries. But this path looks less and less likely as Chile abandons its commitment to freedom and markets.MEET THE WRITER

headshot2.JPG

Jeff Deist

Jeff Deist is president of the Mises Institute. He previously worked as chief of…

Daniel Lacalle on the Biggest Bubble of All

Daniel Lacalle and Jeff Deist discuss why all of us have a stake in seeing central bank balance sheets shrink.

Jim Bovard on the Terrible Politicization of America

Jeff Deist and Jim Bovard take an unflinching look at the disastrous politicization of everything in America.

Mises Institute Press Page
The Human Action Podcast

MEET OUR WIRE CONTRIBUTORS

0089.jpg

Per Bylund

Per Bylund is assistant professor of entrepreneurship & Records-Johnston Professor of Free Enterprise in the…

MORE

TOPICS

AUSTRIAN SCHOOL

BROWSE LIBRARY

ABOUT THE MISES INSTITUTE

CONTACT US

Mises Institute
518 West Magnolia Avenue
Auburn, Alabama 36832-4501

PHONE 334.321.2100 | FAX 334.321.2119

Email Us

Tu ne cede malis,
sed contra audentior ito

STAY CONNECTED

Website powered by Mises Institute donors

Mises is a 4 star charity on Charity Navigator

Mises Institute is a tax-exempt 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. Contributions are tax-deductible to the full extent the law allows. Tax ID# 52-1263436https://s7.addthis.com/static/sh.f48a1a04fe8dbf021b4cda1d.html#rand=0.5106790950952418&iit=1603734836782&tmr=load%3D1603734836681%26core%3D1603734836749%26main%3D1603734836761%26ifr%3D1603734836805&cb=0&cdn=0&md=0&kw=&ab=-&dh=mises.org&dr=&du=https%3A%2F%2Fmises.org%2Fwire%2Fprivilege-politics&href=https%3A%2F%2Fmises.org%2Fwire%2Fprivilege-politics&dt=The%20Privilege%20of%20Politics%20%7C%20Jeff%20Deist&dbg=0&cap=tc%3D0%26ab%3D0&inst=1&jsl=17&prod=undefined&lng=en&ogt=secure_url%2Curl%2Cimage%2Cdescription%2Curl%2Ctype%3Darticle%2Ctitle&pc=men&pub=ra-5c464f0891517916&ssl=1&sid=5f970d34abb9d9ef&srf=0.01&ver=300&xck=0&xtr=0&og=site_name%3DMises%2520Institute%26title%3DThe%2520Privilege%2520of%2520Politics%2520%257C%2520Jeff%2520Deist%26type%3Darticle%26url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn.mises.org%252Fstyles%252Fsocial_media_1200_x_1200%252Fs3%252Fsilence-is-violence1-fb.jpg%253Fitok%253DYF6PfN0V%26description%3DActor%2520Chris%2520Pratt%2520finds%2520himself%2520a%2520target%2520of%2520left%2520Hollywood%2520and%2520various%2520social%2520media%2520enforcers%2520for%2520his%2520apparent%2520lack%2520of%2520support%2520for%2520Joe%2520Biden%252C%2520a%2520sin%2520in%2520his%2520industry.%26image%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn.mises.org%252Fstyles%252Fsocial_media_1200_x_1200%252Fs3%252Fsilence-is-violence1-fb.jpg%253Fitok%253DYF6PfN0V%26secure_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn.mises.org%252Fstyles%252Fsocial_media_1200_x_1200%252Fs3%252Fsilence-is-violence1-fb.jpg%253Fitok%253DYF6PfN0V&csi=undefined&rev=v8.28.7-wp&ct=1&xld=1&xd=123SHARES

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s