” SKIP TO CONTENTSKIP TO SITE INDEXSEARCH & SECTION NAVIGATION Subscribe for $1/week Trump Administration LIVEUpdates 8m ago Birthright Citizenship Order Hegseth Nomination Migrant Deportations Paying for Trump’s Agenda ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT You have been granted access, use your keyboard to continue reading. Trump Leaves Democrats Dazed and on the Defensive Locked out of power in Washington, the party is struggling to agree on a unified message of opposition. Some of its lawmakers are even telling Republicans they want to work together. Listen to this article · 7:43 min Learn more Share full article 438 Gov. Tony Evers of Wisconsin, a Democrat, used his annual State of the State speech this week to defend immigrants. Many other Democratic leaders have been quieter in their pushback to the new administration.Credit…Morry Gash/Associated Press By Reid J. Epstein Reporting from Washington Jan. 24, 2025 Updated 3:03 p.m. ET Sign up for the Tilt newsletter, for Times subscribers only.  Nate Cohn, The Times’s chief political analyst, makes sense of the latest political data. Try it for 4 weeks. Follow our live coverage of the latest news on President Trump. As President Trump pushes aggressively to reshape the federal government, Democrats have retreated into a political crouch that reflects their powerlessness in Washington. Far from rising up in outrage, the opposition party’s lawmakers have taken a muted wait-and-see approach as Mr. Trump tries to end birthright citizenship, halt diversity programs in the federal government, undo foreign policy alliances and seek retribution against his perceived political enemies. In some cases, Democrats are even making a show of working with Republicans. Scores of them voted for the Laken Riley Act, which allows the deportation of unauthorized migrants who are accused but not yet convicted of crimes. Others volunteered to work with Republicans on a border security bill. And while Democrats are fighting the nominations of Pete Hegseth as defense secretary and Tulsi Gabbard as national intelligence director, Mr. Trump’s other cabinet appointees appear on a glide path to confirmation without much vocal resistance. It is telling that in the opening days of the new Trump administration, the loudest pushback to the president’s policies has come not from an elected Democrat but from the bishop at Washington National Cathedral, who asked Mr. Trump directly during a service to have mercy on immigrants and L.G.B.T.Q. children. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT “We’re no longer trying to win a news cycle,” said Senator Brian Schatz of Hawaii, a Democrat who has become an outspoken messenger for his party on social media. “We’re trying to win an argument, and that’s going to take time and patience and discipline.” A group of 70 progressive House Democrats and six Senate Democrats gathered at the Capitol on Thursday to try to settle on a single message of opposition to Mr. Trump as he takes aim at myriad liberal constituencies and priorities. The assembled Democrats concluded that their best course of action was to focus on economic concerns, which they believe led to the party’s November defeats. Representative Greg Casar, a Texas Democrat who is the chairman of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, convened the meeting. He said Mr. Trump’s control of the federal government, combined with his allies’ ownership of major social media networks, meant that Democrats must be in lock step, with a focused message of opposition for voters. “It’s going to be really critical for Democrats to point out what Trump’s real intentions are, which is to screw people over on pocketbook issues in service of the mega-rich,” Mr. Casar said. Image Representative Haley Stevens of Michigan said that fellow Democrats “can’t be in a constant state of hysteria,” but added, “We also don’t want to be Pollyanna.”Credit…Haiyun Jiang for The New York Times The Democratic stance is a stark change from the last time Mr. Trump came to office. That period, in 2017, was defined by public demonstrations of resistance, a flurry of new liberal groups and a palpable anger over an election outcome many in the party saw as illegitimate. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT This time, Mr. Trump won the popular vote and there have been no murmurs of significant foreign interference in the election. And he has unleashed so many new policies and executive orders that Democrats have been left in a daze. “It feels like we’re battling the L.A. fires, and the wind is 100 miles per hour, and it’s zero percent contained,” said Matt Bennett, a founder of Third Way, a center-left think tank. “We’re just going to have to wait for the wind to die down a little. It’s going to be a minute before Democrats can mount an effective response.” Some Democrats do believe Mr. Trump has already made significant mistakes that will cause political damage for him and Republicans. Trump Administration: Live Updates Updated  Jan. 24, 2025, 2:43 p.m. ET29 minutes ago Mike Pence is waging a lonely crusade against Robert F. Kennedy Jr. over his abortion views. Lutnick, Trump’s nominee to lead the Commerce Dept., discloses details of his complex financial interests. Hegseth’s ex-wife who denied physical abuse is bound by a nondisparagement clause. His far-reaching pardons for people convicted of attacking police officers at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, have already led to uncomfortable responses from Republicans. Democrats are also quick to point out that few of Mr. Trump’s early actions have addressed inflation or grocery prices — top issues for voters that he pledged during the campaign to prioritize. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT And in a sign that substantive pushback to Mr. Trump’s policies is likely to come from state capitals rather than from Washington, 22 state attorneys general sued the federal government to block Mr. Trump’s executive order directing the government not to recognize U.S.-born children of unauthorized immigrants as citizens. (However, not all of these left-leaning attorneys general wanted to talk about their legal challenge — in Washington, D.C., the typically voluble top prosecutor did not issue a news release and declined to discuss it.) In Wisconsin, Gov. Tony Evers, a Democrat, devoted 11 paragraphs in his annual State of the State speech on Wednesday night to defending immigrants’ contributions to Wisconsin — though he did not mention Mr. Trump by name. “Wisconsin, we cannot allow reckless decisions in Washington to stymie our economic momentum,” Mr. Evers said. “I will not compromise on our Wisconsin values of treating people with kindness, dignity, empathy and respect.” And in Newark, Mayor Ras J. Baraka on Thursday denounced an immigration raid in which he said a U.S. military veteran was detained. “Newark will not stand by idly while people are being unlawfully terrorized,” Mr. Baraka said. Democratic officials whose constituents are being directly targeted by Mr. Trump’s actions are less willing to give the party time to think about how to respond. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT Cristóbal Alex, a former Biden administration official who is now the chairman of the Latino Victory Fund, ticked through Mr. Trump’s early moves: binding himself to billionaire tech executives, ending Biden-mandated caps on insulin prices, pardoning the Jan. 6 rioters and seeking to end birthright citizenship. “It’s prime time for Democrats to step it up,” Mr. Alex said. And yet plenty of Democrats want to make it known that they are trying to work with the new Trump administration. Thirteen Democratic senators signed a letter to Senator John Thune of South Dakota, the Republican majority leader, asking to be involved in Mr. Trump’s proposed legislation to crack down on the nation’s immigration system. “We stand ready to work with you,” the senators wrote. Some Democratic officials ascribed the party’s hesitation and confusion in part to a lack of clarity from their voters. While anger — and money — drove the so-called Resistance of 2017, Mr. Trump’s second coming has been met by liberal resignation. No one in the world of politics or culture has emerged with a cogent and consistent anti-Trump message since his victory over former Vice President Kamala Harris, and the social media platforms that hosted many of the influencers of eight years ago are now owned by Mr. Trump’s billionaire allies. Patrick Gaspard, the president of the Center for American Progress, a liberal research group, said the lack of Democratic mobilization was not surprising, given that few in the party were shocked by Mr. Trump’s 2024 victory. Democrats, he said, must take time to decide how best to oppose him and Republicans. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT “This guy is throwing loads of chum in the water, and we can’t go after all of it,” Mr. Gaspard said. One think tank’s thoughtfulness is another’s hesitation. Rahna Epting, the executive director of MoveOn, a liberal advocacy group, said elected Democrats were trying to determine what their voters want them to do. “I see Democrats still trying to figure out where to plant their feet on the spectrum of pure opposition and bipartisanship,” Ms. Epting said. “It’s up to constituents and outside groups like MoveOn and others to hold their feet to the fire.” Reid J. Epstein covers campaigns and elections from Washington. Before joining The Times in 2019, he worked at The Wall Street Journal, Politico, Newsday and The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. More about Reid J. Epstein See more on: Democratic Party, Donald Trump, 2024 Elections: News, Polls and Analysis, U.S. Politics, Republican Party READ 438 COMMENTS Share full article 438 More on the Trump Administration Expelling Migrants: The Trump administration is giving ICE officials the power to quickly deport migrants who were allowed under Biden-era programs, according to an internal memo. Rehousing Transgender Prisoners: President Trump told federal prisons to house inmates who are transgender women in men’s facilities and halt medical treatments related to gender transition, part of an executive order meant to limit the recognition of gender to sex at birth. U.S. Plan for Crypto: Trump issued an executive order to support the growth of the cryptocurrency industry, calling for a new plan to regulate a business in which he has substantial investments. A Potential Blow to Trump’s Base: Republicans are mulling deep cuts in safety net spending that would affect struggling working class voters, many of whom helped elect Trump in November. A Global Surge to the Right: Trump has positioned himself at the crest of a global wave of hard-line conservative populism, offering fuel and inspiration to surging nationalist parties in the European Union and beyond. Related Content More in Politics A Heavy Favorite Emerges in the Race to Lead the Democratic Party Jenn Ackerman for The New York Times SKIP ADVERTISEMENT ‘A Bounty on My Head’: Congress’s First Transgender Member Faces the Trump Era Alyssa Schukar for The New York Times ‘The Return of the King’: Trump Embraces Trappings of the Throne Doug Mills/The New York Times Editors’ Picks The Joy — and Awkwardness — of Sober Sex Sara Andreasson A Woman, on Full Show Roadside Attractions, via Associated Press Trending in The Times Review: Malpaso Returns, With Boundless Energy but Little Risk Opinion: How Trump Will Fail The Lumber Sexual Returns How Every Senator Voted to Confirm John Ratcliffe as C.I.A. Director Opinion: This Is Who Should Foot the Bill for the Los Angeles Fires Late Night Enjoys Trump’s Uncomfortable Moment in Church A Ravens Player Dropped a Pass. The Hate It Brought Moved Rivals to Give. Opinion: King Trump A Chef’s Secret to Homemade Chicken Broth Fire Chief Is Fatally Shot After Stopping to Help Driver Who Struck Deer ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT Save on The Times with our best offer:  $1/week for your first year. Learn more Site Index Site Information Navigation © 2025 The New York Times Company NYTCoContact UsAccessibilityWork with usAdvertiseT Brand StudioYour Ad ChoicesPrivacy PolicyTerms of ServiceTerms of SaleSite MapHelpSubscriptions” https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/24/us/politics/trump-democrats-republicans.html#:~:text=SKIP%20TO%20CONTENT,Subscriptions