There is certainly a new flavor of socialism emerging amongst the younger generation.
There is certainly a new flavor of socialism emerging amongst the younger generation. The updated addition to the socialist dogma is tinged with what is called the Me-First perspective, the current rallying cry for a new batch of socialists attempting to upset the economic apple cart. This latest flavor is not too far from the traditional utopian idea that socialism could work somehow if all that is tweaked are price controls, the elimination of private ownership, slowing down market forces, and stifling entrepreneurial incentive and motivation. In other words, the new age socialists’ prevailing cry for a socialist fix to the economy is to upset the apple cart for their own subsidization and effectively taxing everyone else. Put another way, it is about satisfying their wants using your means. Why do they use capitalist means of production to establish a socialist economy? Why doesn’t the new age socialist have a socialist means of production?
The problem with the Gen Z new age socialist frame of thought is that they have no means of production of their own. Put plainly, there are no such things as socialist means of production or economic market tools; if so, what are they? To Gen Z, putting private property in someone else’s hands and tweaking the economy to their benefit sounds workable, but the basic reality is very scary: they are under the impression that a socialist economy will solve their problems, and everyone else’s for that matter, because in their minds all you have to do is control prices, increase minimums, put a cap on this, overtax the other, overregulate this and that, confiscate wealth, and so on. Yet here is the red pill: the previously listed points are capitalist means of production for a market economy; without a socialist means of production, none of the utopian ideas are workable.
Once all individual incentive and motivation tools are defunct, no one will want to or need to do anything for their fellow man and neighbor. Who will be motivated to do anything for anyone else? How will you eat dinner? You cannot destroy incentives for some and expect prosperity for all. They do not know that they eat dinner every night, not because of the benevolence of the butcher; rather, the butcher is incentivized every day to produce meat for us to consume via the market forces and the butcher’s means of production. Take that market means of production away and install overtaxation, kill the profit motive, and decree price floors and ceilings — then we are in trouble. We will all need to resort to eating grass and carrots.
The big problem with both the new and the old socialist doctrines is their attempt to upset the apple cart without having their own socialist means of production to replace the current system. That is when you get crickets. I would love to hear what they would put in place, let us say, if “capitalism” ended tomorrow. Would everyone own everything? How would that work? What would be the method of distribution? How would property renters know how much to reinvest in a property or what the going rates are? Perhaps I am missing something. The problem, as we already know, is that socialism has no productive means to replace this system other than to usurp the capitalist means of production and expect a third party to control it, as if the third party would not pursue its best interest.
The reality is stranger than fiction. What makes the third party less human than anyone else who wants economic ease and prosperity? Would the third-party economic controller want to eat filet mignon instead of chuck steak every night for dinner? Absolutely. And, yes, they want to pay chuck steak prices for filet mignon; who would not? Who does not prefer being subsidized rather than taxed to death? No one. Here is the kicker: in a capitalist system, prime ribs are produced, yes, at a higher price; in a socialist economy, filet mignon would not be considered a real option. But the third party knows very well, and the butcher and the grocer manager know as well, that there’s just not enough of anything to go around, so the fair “capitalist” thing to do is signal to everyone via prices that is shared with millions of people as what they should buy or should not buy, and this is with everything from homes to cars to everything else. People own the means of production and use them for themselves and for everyone else, and consumers’ demands are met by bidding up or down. So, to me, and probably you too, the new age socialists want to upset the apple cart, but without the tools and means of doing so, it is just plainly unworkable. There are no socialist tools for the means of production, at least that I am aware of, so they can demand reform all they want. Really, it is just hot air.
Image: Public Domain
Related Topics: Socialism
SUPPORT AMERICAN THINKER
Now more than ever, the ability to speak our minds is crucial to the republic we cherish. If what you see on American Thinker resonates with you, please consider supporting our work with a donation of as much or as little as you can give. Every dollar contributed helps us pay our staff and keep our ideas heard and our voices strong. Thank you.https://givebutter.com/embed/c/WhA2EO?goalBar=false&gba_gb.element.id=gkx27p
Advertisement
Protein Isn’t Enough – Here’s What Really Builds Muscle After 60ApexLabs
Advertisement
null
Around the web
Advertisement
If You Have Diabetes, Read This Before It’s Removed!Health Weekly
Is It Too Late To Grab The 250th Anniversary Hat Everyone’s Talking About?peoasis
Honey: The Greatest Enemy of Memory Loss (See How to Use It)Health Weekly
Surgeons: This Simple Method Will End Knee Pain & Arthritis Quickly (Try It)Health Weekly
Neurologists: 1/2 Cup Each Morning Relieves Neuropathy Quickly!Health Weekly
Diarrhea or Bloating? Do This Immediately (Watch)HealthMotion
America Turns 250 – and This Patriotic Wreath is EverywhereGlosrity
Greta Thunberg’s House Shocks The Whole World, The Proof In PicsOhi Blog
Why is Everyone Falling for This 250th Anniversary Hat?peoasis
Honey: The Greatest Enemy of Memory Loss (See How to Use It Here)Health Weekly
1 Simple Hack to Save on Your Electric Bill (Try Tonight)Home Criterion
Neurologists: 1/2 Cup Each Morning Relieves Neurоpathy Quickly!Health Weekly
Trending
Advertisement
After 60, Leg Strength Comes From One Simple Daily MoveApexLabs
Cardiologists: 2 Veggies Will Kill Your Belly Fat Like Crazy (Try It)Health Weekly
Surgeons: This Simple Trick Will End Knee Pain & Arthritis Quickly (Try It)Health Weekly
Neurologists: 1/2 Cup Each Morning Relieves Neurоpathy Quickly!Health Weekly
Most ReadLast 24hrsLast 48hrsLast 7 Days
1
Colorado’s Empty Classrooms Are a Warning for America
2
Treason – At Home, at Work, and in the Shipping Department
3
The World Cup Will Expose Los Angeles’ Liberal Illusion
4
A Boston Prof Links Hayek to the ‘Far Right’
5
How to Build an Antifragile Airline
Top ContributorsLast 7 DaysLast 30 Days
Eric Utter
Not satire: Welcome to the George Floyd gift shop!
Bill Ponton
What worked for OJ, might not work for Karmelo Anthony
Brian C. Joondeph
Colorado’s Empty Classrooms Are a Warning for America
Bradley Steffens
Silvio Canto, Jr.
Wonder what Todd Beamer’s widow thinks of this?
SponsoredX
Honey: The Greatest Enemy of Memory Loss (See How to Use It Here)
After 60, Leg Strength Comes From One Simple Daily Move
Surgeons: This Simple Trick Will End Knee Pain & Arthritis Quickly (Try It)
If You Have Diabetes, Read This Before It’s Removed!
America Turns 250 – and This Patriotic Wreath is Everywhere
Remember Her? Try Not to Choke When You See Her Now
Ad Free / Commenting Login
EmailPasswordHOMEARCHIVESCARTOONSSUBMISSIONSABOUTRSS SYNDICATIONPRIVACY POLICYCONTACTDONATE
FOLLOW US ON
© American Thinker 2026null
×
Thank you for making American Thinker part of your routine
Reader support keeps American Thinker independent and accountable only to its audience. Join now and receive 25% off membership in honor of America’s 250th anniversary.
THE ARTFUL DILETTANTE 