Republicans wonder why they keep losing.
Even when they win, the country still drifts left. Despite a few brief interruptions such as Reagan and Trump, the broad undercurrent is clear. This drift has happened over decades, quickly or slowly, even though conservative Americans (not necessarily their leaders) are competent, moral, in touch with reality, and ultimately right on the big issues—at least in theory, and at least compared with their opponents.
But why?
One brief answer: evil has evolved. Good hasn’t evolved—at least, not as quickly, and not as much—yet.
To restate this more clearly: Republicans are fighting an asymmetric war.
Metaphorically speaking, Republicans are fighting with sharp sticks while the left is fighting with pistols and sniper rifles. The left fights with bombs, missiles, drones, and energy weapons while Republicans write strongly worded letters.
Republicans keep wanting to “fight fair.” They insist that in a fair fight, they’d win. Yet they also keep pointing out that the other side doesn’t seem to fight fair. “Sure, they won, but they played dirty.”
Republicans seem to fight according to the old rules of gentlemanly warfare, while the other side utterly disdains those “rules.” Think of the British fighting Native Americans in the 18th Century. They wore their red coats and marched in formation in open fields, while fighting scrappy, nimble opponents in the woods who saw no shame in a strategic retreat. In that sense, it was an asymmetric war, and the outcome didn’t change until the British changed their tactics.
The same dynamic is in effect now. More specifically, Republicans are fighting in the way of traditional American politics while the left is engaged in psychological warfare.
How does this play out in practice?
One example: married couples with children tend to be more conservative. The left understands this well. Therefore, the left works to destroy traditional families.
Another example: individuals who are LGBTQ+ are much more likely to vote left. Therefore, the left encourages individuals to become LGBTQ+ and promotes that lifestyle (especially to young children) at every possible opportunity.
Another example: someone who has had an abortion is much more likely to vote left. Therefore, the left encourages and promotes abortion.
Another example: those who treat human sexuality like a sport—are sexually promiscuous—are more likely to vote left. The right (on paper, at least) officially believes in principled sexuality. Therefore, the left promotes promiscuity, libertinism, and sexual anarchy. (You might be able to guess which side seems more attractive to young people.)
The examples could continue almost indefinitely. Leftists understand that the more agitated, aggrieved, and angry a person is, the more likely some sort of “burn it down” revolution will look attractive. They understand that the more emotionally dysfunctional a person is, the more dependent they become, and therefore more likely to vote for a governmental caretaker. They understand that the more they describe the right as fascists, racists, oppressors, and evil, terrible people, the more people avoid seeing or presenting themselves as “right.” They understand that they need to train and accredit lawyers who will serve as foot soldiers for lawfare. They understand that they need to force doctors to take oaths to the religion of DEI. They understand that they need to maintain their stranglehold on schools and universities because the ability to shape young minds is game, set, and match. And so on.
The left seems to understand all this very thoroughly, and has for decades. If you change a person’s nature, the vote will take care of itself.
Much of the right, in comparison, seems asleep at the wheel. Our side is often reluctant to even discuss these issues. How many parents can make a compelling argument to their children for marrying and starting families, for a principled and intelligent sexuality, against voluntarily experimenting with LGBTQ+ lifestyles, against abortions, against sex-as-sport? How many leaders help parents make these challenging conversations any easier?
Our official leadership (except for Trump) often repeats tired clichés (“children are our future!”) and trots out bland, lifeless sound bites made of stale, cheesy, unpersuasive platitudes.
It isn’t a fair fight.
Far too many on our side still have no idea what time it is and are clueless about the true nature of the fight we’re in. Many Republicans are focused on ball games and barbecues, blissfully imagining it’s still 1996 and that the old, gentlemanly rules still apply. Meanwhile, the country is being hollowed out.
The above might sound dire. It should.
Our side can lose. And it will, unless we get savvy about the nature of the war we’re in. Far too many on our side simply don’t understand the tactics of fifth-generation psychological warfare, don’t understand the enemy, and don’t even have a clue that they’re already engaged in a war at all. If this continues, and the struggle stays asymmetric, an outcome we should all dread is inevitable.
If we don’t revise our approach, America will fall.
It might not “fall” in an obvious, traditional way, where one flag is torn down, and another is raised (although for those with eyes to see, even that is already happening). Instead, it will be hollowed out from within. It will be like a person wearing your friend’s clothes who insists that they are your friend. But that person isn’t your friend.
That said, there is good news. In some ways, we are in a better strategic position. The right, at its best, isn’t spiritually warped, sexually depraved, or existentially lost. Our view of human nature—based on the nature of God, sin, forgiveness, repentance, genuine spirituality, and so on—is more aligned with reality than theirs, which warps and twists human nature into dysfunctional knots of pseudo-moral pretense and misdirected rage.
It’s also good news that some on our side “get it.” Jack Posobiec and Gen. Michael Flynn, for example, seem to understand fifth-generation psychological warfare thoroughly. Trump himself has explained that “the U.S. is now in more danger than it was during World War I, World War II…”—which is exactly the case.
But our political problems won’t be solved on the level of mere politics. A course correction will require, in part, a kind of spiritual revolution. Political healing would follow naturally from spiritual healing.
But for that to happen, more of us will need to start understanding these matters at least as well as the left does. If we change the nature of people, the votes will take care of themselves.
If we keep failing to understand this, we’ll keep losing. But if we understand and act accordingly, we will win.
Steve Rose, American Thinker