Elissa Slotkin’s Coming Inquisition

Public service should not carry a political tax that punishes one side.

Senator Elissa Slotkin has already told us what she wants to be a major priority of the new Democratic Congress when it convenes in January: keeping conservatives out of government service. At a University of Chicago event on October 13, Slotkin laid out the strategy, calling for “signature cases” against “the people who enabled” President Trump so that young conservatives think twice before serving.

“I want young people coming out of school to say, ‘Should I go work for the Trump administration? Like, that sounds fun. I might get an opportunity.’ I want them to be like, ‘Lord, that might be buying myself a ton of problems that I don’t want. And so let me avoid participating in that.’ I want that deterrence message sent.”

This is not congressional oversight. It is a clear threat to raise the personal cost of government service under a Republican president so talented young people stay away. Slotkin’s investigations are the deterrent. The process is the punishment.

Since then, Slotkin has accused Senator Mike Lee of “lying about what I said” and suggested she is only after people who broke the law. But she did not call for investigations of concrete lawbreaking by named officials. She threatened investigations to deter young people from even considering jobs in the Trump administration.

This isn’t news to conservatives like me who worked in executive branch agencies like the CIA and the State Department, where we regularly had to hide our beliefs and values to get ahead and to avoid harassment. Under one manager I had as a CIA analyst, I could not read the conservative Washington Times at my desk because my boss fiercely hated conservatives. My wife, whom I met at the CIA, was harassed because she had a picture of the Bush family in her cubicle. After Bill Clinton won the 1992 presidential election, several conservative analysts took assignments abroad to get away from headquarters because they expected a crackdown on conservatives. They were right, as others and I experienced.

Two senior Foreign Service officers told me they had to keep their conservative views secret to rise in the ranks at State. By the Biden administration, advancing DEI had become a formal requirement for promotion at the State Department and a key criterion for advancement to senior positions at the CIA, where the agency’s diversity chief boasted that DEI had “lifted people up” and “pushed people down.”

For years, selective inquiries, leaks, bogus inspector general investigations, and institutional pressure have raised the costs for conservatives who challenge prevailing views in government, academia, and professional life. In the intelligence community, I watched analysts being pressured to slant their analysis against Republican presidents’ policies. Those who stayed within the consensus and embraced DEI and political correctness advanced. Those who did not openly support these policies were sidelined, fired, or retaliated against.

In transition memos I drafted for the second Trump administration, I proposed reforms to depoliticize our intelligence agencies and make personnel practices fair, especially by ending DEI policies. Many of these reforms have been implemented at State and the Department of War. Some have been implemented in the intelligence community, but more needs to be done. This work is the opposite of what Slotkin proposes: it removes political criteria from hiring and promotion, while she wants to attach a political penalty to serving at all.

Slotkin is proposing to make official the kind of pressure conservatives in government have quietly endured for decades. She stated outright that the objective is to deter conservatives from serving. Slotkin wants young conservative professionals to take notice and choose other careers. Over time, the result she seeks is a federal workforce realigned with the left’s preferred norms, achieved through investigations, harassment, and biased personnel practices.

Public service should not carry a political tax that punishes one side. When a sitting senator openly advocates such a tax, she disgraces her office. The proper response is to strongly condemn Slotkin, document the distinction between legitimate oversight and political harassment of government employees, and insist that policy disputes be settled at the ballot box, not by putting young federal workers in legal jeopardy. Republicans should press incoming Democratic leaders to disavow Slotkin’s approach before the new Congress convenes. Anything less treats her call to target government employees whose political views she dislikes as normal congressional oversight.

My advice to the hundreds of college students I have counseled on government careers is the same today: We need you. Our country needs an ideologically diverse federal workforce, and conservatives should not cede government jobs to the left. Don’t let Slotkin’s threats scare you off. Apply for federal service, do excellent work, keep your head down, and when you are senior enough, fight for fair, nonpolitical standards for everyone. That is how the deep state is dismantled: from the inside, by people who refuse to be deterred.

Fred Fleitz, American Greatness

Leave a Reply